External Hard Drives for PS5, PS4 and Xbox: USB Models Compared

External Hard Drives for PS5, PS4 and Xbox: USB Models Compared
This post includes affiliate links, for which we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you should you make a purchase using our links. As an Amazon Associate, we can earn from qualifying purchases. Learn more. WD’s pages list PS5 and Xbox Series X|S games as stored or archived on the drive and PS4 and Xbox One games as played from it. Read each drive’s console wording before you compare capacity or speed.

Five drives are compared here, four from WD and one from Seagate. WD’s product pages cover the four WD drives, and every Seagate statement comes from its Amazon listing. A drive’s console line says which games it stores and which it plays, so each section quotes what its source says about PS5, PS4, Xbox Series X|S and Xbox One.

ImageProductDetailsCheck Price
WD_BLACK P10 Game Drive 5TB on Amazon
WD_BLACK P10 Game Drive 5TBBest fit: Portable drive for PlayStation and Xbox consoles
Listed capacity: 5TB
Console wording: PS5 and Xbox Series X|S games stored, PS4 and Xbox One games played (WD)
Listed connection: USB 3.2 Gen 1 (WD)
Form: Portable
Check Price on Amazon
WD_BLACK P10 Game Drive for Xbox 5TB on Amazon
WD_BLACK P10 Game Drive for Xbox 5TBBest fit: Portable drive for an Xbox-only setup
Listed capacity: 5TB
Console wording: Xbox Series X|S games archived, Xbox One games played and stored (WD)
Listed connection: USB 3.2 Gen 1 (WD)
Form: Portable
Check Price on Amazon
WD_BLACK D10 Game Drive 8TB on Amazon
WD_BLACK D10 Game Drive 8TBBest fit: Desk drive for PlayStation and Xbox consoles
Listed capacity: 8TB
Console wording: PS5 and Xbox Series X|S games stored, PS4 and Xbox One games played (WD)
Listed connection: USB 3.2 Gen 1 (WD)
Form: Desktop, AC adapter
Check Price on Amazon
WD_BLACK D10 Game Drive for Xbox 12TB on Amazon
WD_BLACK D10 Game Drive for Xbox 12TBBest fit: Largest Xbox library at a desk
Listed capacity: 12TB
Console wording: Xbox Series X|S games archived, Xbox One games stored and played (WD)
Listed connection: USB 3.2 Gen 1 (WD)
Form: Desktop, AC adapter
Check Price on Amazon
Seagate Game Drive for PS4/PS5 5TB on Amazon
Seagate Game Drive for PS4/PS5 5TBBest fit: PlayStation-only setup
Listed capacity: 5TB
Console wording: Archive PS5 games, play PS4 games directly (Amazon title)
Listed connection: USB 3.0 (Amazon title)
Form: Portable (Amazon wording)
Check Price on Amazon

1. WD_BLACK P10 Game Drive 5TB — Best portable drive for PlayStation and Xbox consoles

WD’s P10 page lists PlayStation 5 as “play PS4 games, store PS5 games” and Xbox Series X|S as “play Xbox One games, store Xbox Series X|S games”. It also lists PS4 Pro or PS4 on system software 4.50 or higher, and Xbox One. Amazon’s bullet for this 5TB model describes the same rules as “archive PS5 games” and “archive Xbox Series X|S games”. Neither WD’s page nor Amazon’s bullet says that a PS5 or Xbox Series X|S game plays from the drive.

For the 5TB model WDBA3A0050BBK-WESN, WD lists USB 3.2 Gen 1, a transfer rate of up to 5Gb/s, read speed of up to 130MB/s, and a 4.65 by 3.46 by 0.82 inch body at 0.51 pounds. WD says the speed figure rests on read speed and internal testing and varies with your hardware, and it lists a 3-year limited warranty. Amazon adds a metal top covering, and its title and size field both say 5TB.

The P10 is the portable drive WD lists for both PlayStation and Xbox consoles.

Our Take Pick this P10 when a 5TB drive has to move between a PlayStation and an Xbox, and a PS5 or Series X|S library needs storage space rather than a place to play from.

PROS
  • WD’s P10 page lists PS5, PS4, Xbox Series X|S and Xbox One support, a console list that covers a PlayStation and an Xbox on one drive.
  • WD lists the 5TB P10 at 0.51 pounds and 4.65 by 3.46 by 0.82 inches, a body that suits carrying a library between rooms.
  • WD states a 3-year limited warranty on its own P10 page, a term from the maker and not from an Amazon field.
CONS
  • WD lists PS5 and Xbox Series X|S games as stored on the P10 and PS4 and Xbox One games as played from it, and no source in this guide says a PS5 game plays from the drive.
  • WD lists the P10 at up to 130MB/s, a lower speed than the up to 250MB/s it lists for the D10.

2. WD_BLACK P10 Game Drive for Xbox 5TB — Best portable drive for an Xbox-only setup

WD’s page for the Xbox edition lists Xbox Series X|S as “play and store Xbox One games; archive Xbox Series X|S games” and also lists Xbox One. It names no PlayStation console. Amazon’s listing for this drive is thinner. It says “Gaming Console Device Supported” and USB 3.2 without naming an Xbox model, so the console wording here comes from WD’s page.

WD lists the 5TB model WDBA5G0050BBK-WESN at 4.65 by 3.46 by 0.91 inches and 0.52 pounds, with USB 3.2 Gen 1, up to 130MB/s and a USB Type-A to Micro-B cable in the box. Amazon’s dimension field says 0.82 inches for the same model, so this guide uses WD’s figure. Amazon’s size field and title both say 5TB.

Our Take Choose this P10 for an Xbox-only home that wants 5TB of portable storage. A PlayStation owner should choose a drive that WD or Amazon lists for PlayStation.

PROS
  • WD’s page for this Xbox edition lists Xbox Series X|S and Xbox One support, a console list that matches an Xbox-only setup.
  • WD lists USB 3.2 Gen 1 and up to 130MB/s for this edition, and Amazon lists USB 3.2 as the host interface.
  • WD lists a 0.52-pound body for this edition, close in weight to the other P10.
CONS
  • WD lists Xbox Series X|S games as archived on this drive and Xbox One games as played and stored, and no source in this guide says a Series X|S game plays from it.
  • WD names no PlayStation console for this Xbox edition, and its page gives a PlayStation owner no console line to go by.

3. WD_BLACK D10 Game Drive 8TB — Best desk drive for PlayStation and Xbox consoles

WD’s D10 page gives this 8TB model, WDBA3P0080HBK-NESN, the same console list as the P10, with PS5 and Xbox Series X|S games stored, PS4 and Xbox One games played, and PS4 Pro or PS4 on system software 4.50 or higher. Amazon’s title names PlayStation, Xbox, PC and Mac, but it calls the drive a “Portable External Hard Drive”. WD lists a power supply connector and an AC adapter in the box, and WD and Amazon both give a 7.68 by 4.92 by 1.73 inch body and 980 grams, a size and weight that match a desk drive.

WD lists up to 250MB/s at 7200RPM and active cooling. It also lists two 7.5W USB Type-A ports for charging accessories and a USB Type-A to Micro-B cable. WD says speed is based on read speed and internal testing, and that the drive can stand upright or lie flat. WD’s page lists a 3-year limited warranty.

WD lists an AC adapter for the 8TB D10, whatever the Amazon title says about a portable drive.

Our Take Pick the 8TB D10 for a console setup at a desk where AC power is on hand, and accessory charging and a faster listed speed come before carrying it around.

PROS
  • WD’s D10 page lists PlayStation and Xbox support for this 8TB drive, the same console list as the P10.
  • WD lists the D10 at up to 250MB/s at 7200RPM with active cooling, a higher listed speed than the P10.
  • WD lists two 7.5W USB Type-A ports on this D10 for charging accessories.
CONS
  • Amazon’s title calls this D10 portable, while WD lists an AC adapter and a 980-gram body, and the guide goes by WD’s box contents.
  • WD lists PS5 and Xbox Series X|S games as stored on the D10, not played from it, and no source in this guide says otherwise.

4. WD_BLACK D10 Game Drive for Xbox 12TB — Best for the largest Xbox library

WD’s page for this model, WDBA5E0120HBK-NESN, lists Xbox Series X|S and Xbox One and footnotes the wording as “store and play Xbox One games, archive Xbox Series X|S games”. It names no PlayStation console. Amazon’s bullets list the same two Xbox consoles and describe a collection of up to 300 games, and Amazon’s size field and title say 12TB.

The body is the same size as the 8TB D10, 7.68 by 4.92 by 1.73 inches, and Amazon gives 2.16 pounds. WD and Amazon both list two 7.5W USB Type-A charging ports, a USB Type-A to Micro-B cable, and an AC adapter and plug. WD lists up to 250MB/s at 7200RPM with active cooling and a 3-year limited warranty.

Our Take Choose the Xbox D10 for a permanent Xbox setup where 12TB of space and an AC-powered drive are the goal. A household with a PlayStation should look at the 8TB D10 or the Seagate.

PROS
  • Amazon lists this D10 at 12TB, the largest capacity in this guide, which suits a large Xbox library.
  • WD and Amazon both list an AC adapter, a USB Type-A to Micro-B cable and two 7.5W USB Type-A ports for this D10, the same box contents WD gives the other D10.
  • WD lists this Xbox D10 at up to 250MB/s at 7200RPM with active cooling, a higher listed speed than the P10.
CONS
  • WD lists Xbox Series X|S games as archived on this D10 and Xbox One games as stored and played, and no source in this guide says a Series X|S game plays from it.
  • WD names no PlayStation console for this Xbox D10, so a PlayStation owner would need another drive.

5. Seagate Game Drive for PS4/PS5 5TB — Best for a PlayStation-only setup

Amazon’s title for this Seagate drive reads “Officially Licensed HDD for PlayStation. Archive PS5 games. Play PS4 games directly.” A bullet adds matching firmware for all PS5 and PS4 models, and the title gives 5TB and USB 3.0. The statements about this drive come from the Amazon listing rather than Seagate’s own page, and the listing names no Xbox console.

The listing disagrees with itself in two places. Its bullet describes a blue LED while its color field says “White LED”, so this guide states no light color. Its dimension fields do not match its portable description, so this guide gives no size. FUCHS GOODS, not Amazon.com, holds the New offer. Amazon’s warranty field is empty, so no warranty term is stated here.

Our Take Pick this Seagate for a PlayStation-only home when the archive-and-play wording in its title fits your library. Look at the seller and offer before you buy.

PROS
  • Amazon’s title for this Seagate drive says to archive PS5 games and play PS4 games directly, a console line for PlayStation alone.
  • Amazon’s bullet lists matching firmware for all PS5 and PS4 models, a claim that rests on the listing alone.
  • Amazon’s title states 5TB and USB 3.0 for this Seagate drive, the capacity and interface figures to compare with the WD drives.
CONS
  • FUCHS GOODS, not Amazon.com, holds the New offer for this Seagate drive, and Amazon.com is the seller on the four WD drives.
  • The Amazon listing’s dimension fields do not match its portable description, and its bullet and color field name two LED colors, so this guide gives no size or light color.

Buying Guide

Read the console wording before the capacity

WD’s pages for the P10 and D10 say to play PS4 and Xbox One games from the drive and to store PS5 and Xbox Series X|S games on it. Store and archive mean space for a library, and none of the sources in this guide says a PS5 or Xbox Series X|S game plays from these drives. Seagate’s Amazon title uses the same split in PlayStation terms.

Check the consoles each source names. WD names no PlayStation console for either Xbox edition, and Seagate’s Amazon listing names PS5 and PS4 but no Xbox. For the P10 and the 8TB D10, WD names both PlayStation and Xbox consoles.

Choose a portable or a desk drive

WD lists the 5TB P10 at 0.51 pounds and the P10 for Xbox at 0.52 pounds, both 4.65 by 3.46 inches. WD lists the D10 body at 980 grams with an AC adapter in the box, and the 8TB and 12TB D10 share the 7.68 by 4.92 by 1.73 inch size. The Amazon title for the 8TB D10 says portable, so go by WD’s box contents.

WD lists up to 130MB/s for the P10 and up to 250MB/s for the D10. WD says both figures rest on read speed and internal testing and vary with your hardware, so treat them as stated ceilings. A capture card or a console gaming monitor solves a different job from storage and does not change a drive’s console wording.

Check the seller and the Amazon fields

On November 13, Amazon showed Amazon.com as the New buy-box seller for the four WD drives and FUCHS GOODS for the Seagate. Used offers from other sellers also appear on some of the WD listings, so confirm the offer you open says New before you buy.

The Seagate listing’s own fields conflict on LED color and dimensions, and Amazon’s warranty field is empty. Compare the model number on the box with STLV5000202, the model Amazon lists, before you rely on any figure from that listing.

FAQ

Can these drives play PS5 or Xbox Series X|S games?

WD’s pages list PS5 and Xbox Series X|S games as stored on the drive, and PS4 and Xbox One games as played from it. Seagate’s Amazon title says to archive PS5 games and play PS4 games directly.

None of these sources says a PS5 or Xbox Series X|S game plays from the drive. A drive’s size and speed do not change what its source lists for each console.

Is the D10 better than the P10?

WD lists up to 250MB/s for the D10 and up to 130MB/s for the P10, and Amazon lists 8TB or 12TB for the D10 against 5TB for the P10. WD also lists an AC adapter and a 980-gram body for the D10, against a 0.51-pound body for the P10.

Pick the P10 to carry a library between rooms and the D10 for a fixed desk with a power outlet. Portable or desktop is the first decision, and the console list comes second.

Which drive suits an Xbox-only setup?

WD’s page for the P10 Game Drive for Xbox lists Xbox Series X|S and Xbox One, and Amazon lists 5TB. WD’s page for the D10 Game Drive for Xbox lists the same two consoles, and Amazon lists 12TB.

The 5TB Xbox P10 is the portable one, and the 12TB Xbox D10 needs AC power per WD’s box contents. Choose by how much space the library needs and whether the drive travels.

Bottom Line

The WD_BLACK P10 5TB is the portable drive WD lists for PlayStation and Xbox consoles, and the 8TB D10 is the desk version of the same console list. The 12TB Xbox D10 has the most space for an Xbox owner, and the Seagate fits a PlayStation-only home that accepts an Amazon-listing source.

How this guide was built: WD’s product pages for the four WD drives and the Amazon listings for all five were read on November 13. The Seagate statements rest on its Amazon listing alone. Each drive’s console line is quoted from its source, and the guide gives no price or warranty from an Amazon field.
Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related Posts